Have you, like catmanager, been wondering why Menu Foods is importing wheat gluten when wheat is grown all across Canada and the United States? More generally, why does the United States import 70 percent of all the wheat gluten it consumes? Even more generally, what is wheat gluten?
Catmanager confesses he had a misperception about wheat gluten. I thought it was simply a part of the wheat. Seems I forgot my high school biology: the wheat seed, or kernel, comprises the bran, the germ, and the endosperm (here’s a diagram). But I wasn’t completely off. I was just thinking macro rather than micro. Gluten is found in the cells of grains like wheat.
First, a little about cells. They contain both living and nonliving substances. The living substance is the protoplasm. The nonliving substances include carbohydrates, proteins, crystals, and fats, collectively referred to as ergastic substances. If a cell were a store, the employees would be the protoplasm and the ergastic substances would be the inventory.
Gluten is an ergastic protein. Specifically, an
amorphous mixture of proteins found combined with starch in the endosperm of some cereals, notably wheat, rye, and barley. It constitutes about 80% of the proteins contained in wheat, and is composed of the proteins gliadin and glutenin.
Wheat gluten, then, isn’t something easily separated from the rest of its wheat-ly components (you can’t simply thresh the wheat to get to it). In Western food culture, the wheat gluten is generally not removed, becuase it is needed to give breads their “chewy” quality and for leavening to occur.
The Chinese were the first to figure out how to extract wheat gluten. The process is relatively simple: form a simple water and flour dough; then rinse and knead the dough with fresh water until it is free of starch and bran. The resulting sticky lump is wheat gluten. When cooked, it becomes firm and will absorb flavors from the ingredients with which it is cooked. Wheat gluten as a stand-alone food product is widely used throughout Asia, often as a meat substitute. (If you’ve ever been to an Asian foods market and wondered about all the fake meat products in the frozen-foods section—imitation beef, turkey, chicken, squid, catfish, etc.—those are all made with wheat gluten. So, oddly, is Tofurkey.) In the West stand-alone wheat gluten is more commonly called seitan, and unless you’re a vegetarian or on a macrobiotic diet, the chances are good you haven’t eaten any or at least haven’t been aware of eating it (the stuff is included in some processed foods).
Now the import of wheat gluten to the United States makes a bit more sense. It’s just not as widely used here as in other parts of the world, so it’s more economical to import what we do need. What surprises catmanager is where we get our wheat gluten from. In 2006 the United States imported $141.5 million worth of wheat gluten, almost double the amount in 2001. Most came from Europe. Less than 1 percent came from Asia, and less than 0.01 percent came from China. Catmanager wonders what portion of that amount went to Menu Foods.
(Note: I obtained the trade data from the U.S. Department of State TradeStats Express Web site. Just before posting, I checked the site again and found it to be nonfunctional. All I see is a blank, white page or a server error.)
26 March 2007 at 2:14 pm
A little history on the wheat gluten industry, though only through 2004:
http://www.ampc.montana.edu/briefings/briefing76.pdf
I researched wheat gluten last week as I didn’t know what it was either. I DID eat seitan once at a veg place. It was tasteless and had a disgusting texture.
BTW, MGP quit selling wheat gluten to MenuFoods 18 months ago. Hmmmmm
Want some?
http://www.made-in-china.com/trade-offers/offerviewQMoEyFdlEJRs/Sell-Wheat-Gluten.html
Trade battles: http://www.tradeobservatory.org/headlines.cfm?refID=16347
And while you’re at this site Browse under the topic of Food Safety.
26 March 2007 at 7:54 pm
Wheat gluten is a major export of Europe. Hmm. This is curious. News reports of the South African dry pet food recall (contaminated with ethylene glycol) which time-wise closely parallels the Menu Foods recall, reported that a raw ingredient, which the company, Aquanutro, refused to identify, had been imported from Europe–the identity of the supplier was also withheld.
Is there any way to find out the raw material implicated in the South African recall. It’d be interesting to know if it, too, was wheat gluten. And, if not, what was it?
How can corporations get away with poisoning consumers’ pets and still be afforded the luxury of withholding information from the public? Aquanutro withheld both the identity of the contaminated raw ingredient and its European supplier; Menu Foods has refuse to name the supplier of the wheat germ they suspect is the contaminant’s source, other than to say it came from China. Don’t we, as consumers, deserve full disclosure from these companies?
27 March 2007 at 7:54 am
[...] Added on 3/27/07: I just can’t let this wheat gluten thing go, so thought I’d share an interesting read I just found over on vetcetera. [...]
26 December 2008 at 3:45 am
well, hi admin adn people nice forum indeed. how’s life? hope it’s introduce branch
25 July 2009 at 7:48 am
China has a severe population problem, and the Aminopterin which was found in the wheat gluten from China is an abortifacient. (It induces abortions.)
Now I’m just guessing here, but perhaps that Chinese gluten was never intended for animal consumption.
It makes perfect sense, that the government would want to reduce the fertility of the population, and puts an additive in the food to accomplish this.
10 November 2009 at 9:48 pm
Cathy, seitan is just a base.
It tastes however you flavor it, and it can have virtually any texture you want it to have.
2 December 2009 at 3:54 am
i just wanted a yes or no answer